Ottawa River=GROSS!!

This is where it's all going on. One can ask for advice or general information or simply chew the fat about fishing tackle, tips, and locations.
User avatar
MichaelVandenberg
Silver Participant
Silver Participant
Posts: 736
Joined: Wed Mar 12, 2003 9:44 am
Location: Ontario

Post by MichaelVandenberg »

Jimmy from the Valley wrote: People in Ottawa in some areas pay between $4500 to $10K annually in property taxes!! :shock:

You mean to say that there is no $$$ to put toward sewage upgrades? Additional capacity? Look at Kanata with the floods and how they have screwed up many flood plain calculations.....

Glad I live in the country....
The money has been spent on a great light rail system in Ottawa that we all should be proud of :roll: :shock: :roll: :shock: :roll: :shock: :roll: :shock: :roll:
User avatar
Jimmy_1
Diamond Participant
Diamond Participant
Posts: 3332
Joined: Thu May 08, 2008 1:51 pm

Post by Jimmy_1 »

You're right Michael...and twice at that! :shock:
User avatar
Yannick Loranger
Gold Participant
Gold Participant
Posts: 1046
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2008 11:40 am
Location: Rockland

Post by Yannick Loranger »

Ok, here's my take on this.
I eat fish from the Ottawa River. It tastes like it does on pristine lakes up north. The animals that eat the fish aren't dying. There are no floating turds in the river. Something like 0.001% (don't quote me on that) of the "sewage" that is spilled into the river, is actually raw sewage, the rest is excess rainwater. It is ok for people to swim in most of the time. All kinds of animal poop is swept into the river every time and rains, been that way for thousands of years. If it was really a big problem, we'd have ridiculous weed growth all over the river, worst case scenario, you can't swim in the river and there's slop for largies all over the place. I think the media has blown this WAY out of proportion.

I think what's important to remember here is that this isn't a lake, it's a river that has millions (if not billions) of liters of water that flow through it each day, any type of sediment is washed away quickly. Is it ok that the City does nothing about this...absolutely not, but these "sewage" spills, won't keep me from enjoying a few walleye fillets now and then.

My 2 cents.

Yannick
User avatar
smokercraft
Participant
Participant
Posts: 80
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 7:46 am
Location: Ottawa

Post by smokercraft »

almontefisher wrote:My father sold sewer and water pipe for 40years to this city and he has told them for the last 25years that they need to upgrade and improve thier systems. He said this about Orleans and their systems( all the flooding ) he said it about Kanata and he said it about all this stuff. The sewer pipes are not large enough to handle some of the flow from all the build up of homes and also the pumps are to small to keep up with moving it. 25 years he told them to fix this before it is too late and instead they purchase the cheapest pipe, pumps etc to be able to use your $$$ on other things like repaving the 417 15 times in 10 years etc. They knew what they were doing and it is biting them in the butt now. As for the raw sewage going in yes a lot of it is grey water but a good portion is raw sewage. Has it been going on for 40years...No not at this level unless half the city population back then went to the bathroom an awful lot. How can anyone say it is just as bad as it was when we have doubled the population and not increased the infrastructure to support this. Again when 40 years ago the population was what 200,000 tops and now it is 1,000,000....how can anyone say it is the same???
OK..... I have commented on here a few times now about the true story of what is happening, I know because I actually work with it every day. Don't take this the wrong way Almontefisher, but people actually need to get their facts together before they comment on this stuff. First off, the treatment we have now is 1000 times better than what we were doing years and years ago. Until 16 years ago, Ottawa only had what is called "primary" treatment of raw sewage, basically that means that the big stuff was screened out and then it went straight to the river. Now, we have what is called secondary treatment as well as some tertiary treatment. Basically all of the dissolved solids are also removed and the remaining water or "effluent" is dissinfected to kill bacteria before it is put into the river. The overflows we are hearing about are from sewer pipes that are buried under the city, mainly downtown. When the sewers were installed decades and decades ago, like 1950 they put in some of what are called "combined" sewers, these are pipes that carry both the drainage water (from roads, ditches etc) and also sewage together in the same pipe. These pipes have an overflow weir in them so that when the pipe gets full to its maximum capacity, it overflows and goes directly to the river. This is done because if it doesn't, everyone would have 8 feet of sewer/stormwater coming into their basements from the sewer pipes that run from your house (it would backup into your basements). Yes, it can be fixed completely.... would cost tens of billions to tear up all of Ottawa and replace these sewers. Also when these overflows happen, it is because of a rain event and there is an influx of rainwater making these pipes fill up so fast, therefore it is very diluted as far as the sewage content is concerned, likely about 95% stormwater. What we need to remember is that Ottawa is ranked around number 8 in the country as having the best environmentally sewer system. Most cities, such as Halifax, PEI, Vancouver, I think Montreal, Kingston... they have either primary treatment only or in some places no treatment at all, it goes straight to the waterways to be disposed of. Montreal just did an upgrade and it used to go straight to the St Lawrence... Halifax to the ocean, Vancouver to the ocean,..... etc etc.... You only hear about Ottawa, Gatineau puts as much or more in the river as Ottawa does, don't hear about them.... What about Renfrew, Arnprior, Deep River, Pembroke? It gets done everywhere!!! The Ottawa river flows at approx 500 MILLION litres per second! Studies show that waterways can accept up to 10% by volume of sewage without adverse effects on the ecosystem. I agree it is not a good thing, the city is trying to fix it, just spent millions on it, going to keep trying to improve it.... It is just a media frenzy now because people are lapping it up without knowing the truth of what they are really being told. Just like the radioactivity thing that was going on with the sewage last winter... It was determined that it was faulty detection systems at the border that gave a false reading. The media were invited to a meeting with council, Canada Nuclear and Border officials and informed that it was a mistake on their part. They were asked to report it in the papers that it was a false alarm and they said that they would not report on it... basically good news doesn't sell, that pretty much explains everything right there
User avatar
smokercraft
Participant
Participant
Posts: 80
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 7:46 am
Location: Ottawa

Post by smokercraft »

OK..... I have commented on here a few times now about the true story of what is happening, I know because I actually work with it every day. Don't take this the wrong way Almontefisher, but people actually need to get their facts together before they comment on this stuff. First off, the treatment we have now is 1000 times better than what we were doing years and years ago. Until 16 years ago, Ottawa only had what is called "primary" treatment of raw sewage, basically that means that the big stuff was screened out and then it went straight to the river. Now, we have what is called secondary treatment as well as some tertiary treatment. Basically all of the dissolved solids are also removed and the remaining water or "effluent" is dissinfected to kill bacteria before it is put into the river. The overflows we are hearing about are from sewer pipes that are buried under the city, mainly downtown. When the sewers were installed decades and decades ago, like 1950 they put in some of what are called "combined" sewers, these are pipes that carry both the drainage water (from roads, ditches etc) and also sewage together in the same pipe. These pipes have an overflow weir in them so that when the pipe gets full to its maximum capacity, it overflows and goes directly to the river. This is done because if it doesn't, everyone would have 8 feet of sewer/stormwater coming into their basements from the sewer pipes that run from your house (it would backup into your basements). Yes, it can be fixed completely.... would cost tens of billions to tear up all of Ottawa and replace these sewers. Also when these overflows happen, it is because of a rain event and there is an influx of rainwater making these pipes fill up so fast, therefore it is very diluted as far as the sewage content is concerned, likely about 95% stormwater. What we need to remember is that Ottawa is ranked around number 8 in the country as having the best environmentally sewer system. Most cities, such as Halifax, PEI, Vancouver, I think Montreal, Kingston... they have either primary treatment only or in some places no treatment at all, it goes straight to the waterways to be disposed of. Montreal just did an upgrade and it used to go straight to the St Lawrence... Halifax to the ocean, Vancouver to the ocean,..... etc etc.... You only hear about Ottawa, Gatineau puts as much or more in the river as Ottawa does, don't hear about them.... What about Renfrew, Arnprior, Deep River, Pembroke? It gets done everywhere!!! The Ottawa river flows at approx 500 MILLION litres per second! Studies show that waterways can accept up to 10% by volume of sewage without adverse effects on the ecosystem. I agree it is not a good thing, the city is trying to fix it, just spent millions on it, going to keep trying to improve it.... It is just a media frenzy now because people are lapping it up without knowing the truth of what they are really being told. Just like the radioactivity thing that was going on with the sewage last winter... It was determined that it was faulty detection systems at the border that gave a false reading. The media were invited to a meeting with council, Canada Nuclear and Border officials and informed that it was a mistake on their part. They were asked to report it in the papers that it was a false alarm and they said that they would not report on it... basically good news doesn't sell, that pretty much explains everything right there
User avatar
Eli
Silver Participant
Silver Participant
Posts: 982
Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2006 11:04 am
Location: Cantley

Post by Eli »

smokercraft wrote:You only hear about Ottawa, Gatineau puts as much or more in the river as Ottawa does, don't hear about them....
according to 2006 census...
population of Gatineau: 242,124
population of Ottawa: 812,000

now, how can Gatineau possibly be putting as much crap into the river as Ottawa if they have 1/4 the population????? it must be those poutines...
User avatar
smokercraft
Participant
Participant
Posts: 80
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 7:46 am
Location: Ottawa

Post by smokercraft »

Sorry about the multiple post, it says that it wasn't posting but it obviously was...... Gatineau has a lot less people but the amount of untreated water that goes to the river from both wastewater and stormwater is huge
User avatar
smokercraft
Participant
Participant
Posts: 80
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 7:46 am
Location: Ottawa

Post by smokercraft »

"Waste from older neighbourhoods between Aylmer and Buckingham doesn’t necessarily go to Gatineau’s sewage treatment plant on Notre-Dame and Campeau streets. Much of it flows into the river through 96 storm water outlets.

Quebec Ministry of Municipal Affairs records show that Gatineau released sewage into the Ottawa and La Lievre rivers 1,231 times in 2005. City staff don’t have any estimate of the amount of sewage that is dumped, but Quebec Ministry of Environment officials say river water quality meets most provincial standards.

Gatineau’s combined storm and sanitary sewers can handle up to three times the normal flow from rainfall, but when there is too much water, the excess water and sewage is directed automatically into the river rather than toward the city’s sewage treatment plant."
User avatar
smokercraft
Participant
Participant
Posts: 80
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 7:46 am
Location: Ottawa

Post by smokercraft »

Here is a good link to see how it is not an "Ottawa" problem but an issue in nearly every province..... Again, I think it is terrible as well, I am a fishermen, hunter and outdoor enthusiast as much as anyone on here. I am just tired of hearing Ottawa this ,Ottawa that, everyone should be fired, we are a disgrace to our country etc....

http://www.infc.gc.ca/research-recherch ... 2-eng.html
User avatar
smokercraft
Participant
Participant
Posts: 80
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 7:46 am
Location: Ottawa

Post by smokercraft »

Another good one.... Keep in mind that this is from 2004

http://roguepundit.typepad.com/roguepun ... world.html
RJ
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 8445
Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2003 9:18 pm
Location: Prospect, Ontario

Post by RJ »

Thank you for posting some "facts" Smokercraft....from someone who actually knows whats gone on....not just by what they read in the Ottawa Sun.....

The Ottawa Sun.....you need a Grade 4 Education to be able to read it....and a Grade 2 Education to write for them... :lol:

RJ
User avatar
almontefisher
Diamond Participant
Diamond Participant
Posts: 2971
Joined: Tue Oct 17, 2006 3:08 pm
Location: Carleton Place

Post by almontefisher »

That is great info smokercraft and I did not take it the wrong way at all. I guess I was talking more about the newer developments in the Ottawa area and I guess most of this waste water is central location and east area. But I can guarantee you that they do not have sufficient sewer systems to keep up with the increase of population. They have way to small main lines from these newer areas which will cause more flooding than anything.

But wow I thank you for all that info. Some I understood :lol: but it is good to get the info from the horses mouth...Now you don't take that the wrong way :lol:
Wallyboss
Diamond Participant
Diamond Participant
Posts: 4824
Joined: Tue Jun 29, 2004 7:44 pm
Location: Carlsbad Springs

Post by Wallyboss »

It is the second time that smokercraft has said these comments, right after I read his first post about it I have put my mind to ease about fishing in the Ottawa. We also have a water quality tester for the city of Ottawa who is a a Hawktalker and he told me that E-Coli doesn't accumulate in fish flesh and that most of it is killed by cold temps. So yes I eat fish from the Ottawa but mostly when I am ice fishing or during the spring walleye hunt.
When hell freezes over, I'll be there icefishing!!!

If you can't stand behind our troops,
Please feel free to stand in front of them!!!

Experience is that marvellous thing that enables you to recognize a mistake when you make it again
User avatar
Andy_L
Gold Participant
Gold Participant
Posts: 1457
Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2007 7:23 am
Location: Carleton Place

Post by Andy_L »

thanks AGAIN Smokercraft...I know you have replied to this kind of thread in the past and its very nice of you to repeat yourself again...hopefully the FACTS you present will slow down the sensationalism here that the media makes of these types of things

again, Thank you
User avatar
Mick
Silver Participant
Silver Participant
Posts: 562
Joined: Fri Nov 15, 2002 1:32 pm
Location: Orleans

Post by Mick »

a good friend of mine is in the water quality testing business

he tells me that the levels in the river are negligible.....he also says that the difference bewteen the river and most lakes in eastern ontario is that the river is constantly tested. He says if the lakes were tested with the same scrutiny, very few of them would be found to have lower levels than the big O.

that is what i was told by someone with a lot more knowledge of the issue than i have.
Post Reply